Shopping on line can be easy, simple and save you lots of money. It can also take a lot of your time, frustrate you, and result in unwanted purchases. Now the same can be said for regular high street shopping, but with the vast opportunity presented by the Internet it will pay you to spend a few minutes reading this and understanding how to better optimize your Invention Of Radio shopping experience:
1. Compare - without doubt the biggest advantage that the Invention Of Radio offers shoppers today is the ability to compare thousands of Invention Of Radio at a time. This is a great thing, but not necessarily all the time! Too much can be daunting at times so take advantage of the great comparison sites and where possible let them do the hard work for you.
2. Research - if it has been said it will be on the internet. Ignorance is no longer a justifiable reason for buying the wrong thing. Take the time to research in detail everything that you could possible want to know about
3. Testimonials - don't know anybody that has bought a Invention Of Radio? Wrong! If the Invention Of Radio is good the internet will let you know. Use the Internet as a friend and get testimonials before you buy.
4. Questions - Got a question about Invention Of Radio then search the Forums, FAQ's, Blogs etc. Don't be afraid to ask .....
5. Reputation - Never heard of the company selling Invention Of Radio? Don't worry, no reason why you should know every company in the world, but you know someone that does! Use the internet to find out what people are saying about Invention Of Radio and build up a picture of their reputation for sales, returns, customer service, delivery etc.
6. Returns - still worried that even after all of the above your Invention Of Radio wont be what you want? Check out the returns policy. There is so much competition now that someone, somewhere is bound to offer the terms that you are comfortable with.
7. Feedback - happy with your Invention Of Radio then let people know, after all you are depending on others people input in your buying decision, so why not give a little back.
8. Security - check for the yellow padlock on the Invention Of Radio site before you buy, and the s after http:/ /i.e. https:// = a secure site
9. Contact - got a question about Invention Of Radio, or want to leave a comment then check out the sites contact page. Reputable companies have them and respond.
10. Payment - ready to pay for your Invention Of Radio, then use your credit card or PayPal! Be aware of companies that don't accept them, there may be genuine reasons but given the huge amount of choice you have when buying online there is no reason at all not to buy via credit card or PayPal.
This article covers the main arguments about who had what part in the early development of radio.
For the general history of radio, see History of radio.
Within the
timeline of radio, many people were involved in the
invention of radio transmission of information as we know it today. Despite this, during its early development and long after wide acceptance, disputes persisted as to who could claim sole credit for this obvious boon to mankind.
Early wireless work
Scientific theory and verification
James Clerk Maxwell performed the theoretical physical research that correctly predicted the existence of radio (and all other electromagnetic) waves.
Heinrich Rudolf Hertz was the experimental physicist who created radio waves in a controlled laboratory manner. Neither Maxwell nor Hertz, though, devised systems for actual general use or described the application of the technology.
Developments, parallel to these individuals and after, are engineering investigations that lead to the '
invention of radio': the objects, processes, or techniques of information transception. Many individuals contributed to the art of wireless, in the air, earth, and water; this includes the precursory work in
wireless telephony and wireless telegraphy.
SLF and UHF experimentation
David E. Hughes, eight years before Hertz's experiments and nearly two decades before Guglielmo Marconi demonstrations, induced electromagnetic waves in a signalling system. Hughes transmitted Morse code by an
Electromagnetic induction apparatus. In 1878, Hughes's induction transmission method utilized a "clockwork transmitter" to transmit signals. In 1885,
Thomas Alva Edison used a vibrator magnet for induction transmission. In 1888, Edison deployed a system of signalling on the Lehigh Valley Railroad. In 1891, Edison attained the wireless patent for this method using inductance ().
From 1886 to 1888 inclusive in his classic
Ultra high frequency experiments, Heinrich Rudolf Hertz had proved that the properties of radio waves were consistent with Maxwell’s electromagnetic theory. He demonstrated that radio radiation had all the properties of waves (now called Transverse waves), and discovered that the electromagnetic equations could be reformulated into a partial differential equation called the
wave equation.
Of the three basic forms of wireless aerial launching structures, the
Hertz antenna was a center-fed half-
wavelength dipole antenna (with the other forms being the Marconi antenna and
Tesla antenna). Hertz’s setup for a source and detector of radio waves (archaically called
Hertz waves in his honor) comprised a primitive radio system capable of transmitting and receiving space waves through free space. Hertz wave His transmitter was not at all efficient and was severely limited in power output. Its dipole antenna differed from the vertical quarter-wavelength antenna that was subsequently adopted by Marconi and others in that it was not grounded. Peterson, Gary, "
Comparing the Hertz-wave and Tesla wireless systems". Feed Line No. 9 Article
Hertz used the damped oscillating currents in a dipole antenna, triggered by a high-voltage electrical capacitive spark discharge, as his source of radio waves. His detector in some experiments was another dipole antenna connected to a narrow spark gap. A small spark in this gap signified detection of the radio wave. When he added cylindrical reflectors behind his dipole antennas, Hertz could detect radio waves about 20 metres from the
transmitter in his
laboratory. He did not try to transmit further because he wanted to prove Electromagnetism theory, not to develop wireless
communications.
Hertz seemed uninterested in the practical importance of his experiments. He stated that "
It's of no use whatsoever ... this is just an experiment that proves Maestro James Clerk Maxwell was right - we just have these mysterious electromagnetic waves that we cannot see with the naked eye. But they are there." Eugenii Katz, "
Heinrich Rudolf Hertz". Biographies of Famous Electrochemists and Physicists Contributed to Understanding of Electricity, Biosensors & Bioelectronics.Asked about the ramifications of his discoveries, Hertz replied, "
Nothing, I guess." Hertz also stated, "I do not think that the wireless waves I have discovered will have any practical application." Hertz died in 1894, so the art of radio was left to others to implement into a practical useful form. His discoveries would later be taken up by entrepreneurs looking to make their fortunes. Marconi's 1895 experiments followed Hertz's work (among others) by using a spark source in what became known as a
spark-gap transmitter.
Tesla's work
: Serbian/Croatian/Austro-Hungarian/American inventor, physicist, mechanical engineer and electrical engineer who some people regard as one of the most important inventors in history.
Radio frequency generation
Nikola Tesla was one of the first to patent a means to reliably produce radio frequency currents. Tesla's , "
Method of Operating Arc-Lamps" (March 10, 1891), describes an alternator that produced high-frequency current (for that time period), around 10,000 cycles per second. (The term cycles-per-second was later modified to "
hertz.") His
patentable innovation was suppression of the sound produced by arc lamps that were operated on alternating or pulsating current by using frequencies beyond the range of human hearing. The alternator produced frequencies in the Very Low Frequency (VLF) band.
Continued research and patents
Around July 1891, he established his
New York laboratory and constructed various apparatuses that produced between 15,000 to 18,000 cycles per second. At this location, he also lit vacuum tubes wirelessly (thus providing hard evidence for the potential of wireless transmissions). Transmission and radiation of radio frequency energy was a feature exhibited in the experiments by Tesla and was noted early on to be used for the
telecommunication of
information."
On Light and Other High Frequency Phenomena". Delivered before the Franklin Institute, Philadelphia, February 1893, and before the National Electric Light Association, St. Louis, March 1893."
Experiments with Alternating Currents of High Potential and High Frequency". Delivered before the Institution of Electrical Engineers, London, February 1892.
In 1892, Tesla delivered a widely reported presentation before the
Institution of Electrical Engineers of London in which he noted, among other things, that intelligence would be transmitted without wires. Later, a variety of Tesla's radio frequency systems were demonstrated during another widely known lecture, presented to meetings of the National Electric Light Association in St. Louis, Missouri and the Franklin Institute in
Philadelphia. According to the IEEE, "
the apparatus that he employed contained all the elements of spark and continuous wave that were incorporated into radio"."
Nikola Tesla, 1856 - 1943". IEEE History Center, IEEE, 2003.
In late 1896 or early 1897 Tesla received wireless signals transmitted from the Houston St. lab in New York City to West Point, New York, "a distance of about 30 miles." The transmitter consisted of an RF alternator and produced
Continuous wave Low frequency. The receiver consisted of a powerful electromagnet, two large condensers, and a taut steel wire. The wire was placed within the magnetic field, and in conjunction with the condensers formed a tuned circuit."Nikola Tesla On His Work with Alternating Currents and Their Application to wireless Telegraphy, Telephony, and Transmission of Power", Leland I. Anderson, Twenty First Century Books, 2002, pp. 26-27.]
PBS: Marconi and Tesla: Who invented radio? In 1899 Tesla established an "Experimental Station" in Colorado Springs where he continued his research into wireless transmission principles often using a form of electrical oscillator known as the magnifying transmitter.
.Early on in his research Tesla used his high voltage resonance transformer—the
Tesla coil—in radio-wave propagation experiments. The
Antenna (radio)#Antenna parameters consisted of a top-loaded electrical conductor that was connected to a high-voltage terminal of the transformer. The opposing high-voltage terminal was grounded. The secondary winding was driven by a primary circuit consisting of a few turns of heavy wire, a capacitor bank, a circuit controller, and a power supply transformer. The launching structure radiated as a common "Hertz wave" antenna. In Tesla's own words,"The popular impression is that my wireless work was begun in 1893, but as a matter of fact I spent the two preceding years in investigations, employing forms of apparatus, some of which were almost like those of today. . . .""
The True Wireless"After a while he began to favor another technique that he called the “disturbed charge of ground and air method.” Tesla's wireless system used the same basic apparatus, however instead of using electromagnetic space waves the energy is carried by the conduction of electrical currents through the earth and along with accompanying surface waves. In one form of the system the ‘return’ path closing the circuit is an electrical current flow established between two elevated terminals, one belonging to the transmitter and the other the receiver. These consist of conduction currents flowing through plasma and also electrostatic induction. Once again in Tesla's own words,". . . It was clear to me from the very start that the successful consummation could only be brought about by a number of radical improvements. Suitable high frequency generators and electrical oscillators had first to be produced. The energy of these had to be transformed in effective transmitters and collected at a distance in proper receivers. Such a system would be manifestly circumscribed in its usefulness if all extraneous interference were not prevented and exclusiveness secured. In time, however, I recognized that devices of this kind, to be most effective and efficient, should be designed with due regard to the physical properties of this planet and the electrical conditions obtaining on the same. . . .""
ibid"In other words, Tesla’s structure injected a large alternating current into the earth via the ground terminal. Tesla's discovery of importance was the "
Surface wave" method. The production of surface waves as described by Arnold Sommerfeld and Jonathan Zenneck was partially the consequence of adding a deep ground connection to the transmitter. Tesla said in 1893 that "
One of the terminals of the source would be connected to Earth a Ground (electricity) ...]
the other to an insulated body of large surface."
On Light and Other High Frequency Phenomena". Delivered before the Franklin Institute, Philadelphia, February 1893, and before the National Electric Light Association, St. Louis, March 1893.
A shallow buried ground plane or an elevated insulated counterpoise is commonly used in the construction of low and medium frequency 1/4-wavelength radio antennas. These lend to the development of the Norton Surface Wave. This method led to longer transmission ranges. Many AM stations use this same principle to boost reception of their signals."
Why AM Radio Stations Must Reduce Power, Change Operations, or Cease Operations at Night". fcc.gov. This also allow modern grounded AM 1/4 wavelength monopole antenna to be more practical in order to overcome the restrictions imposed upon designers by the large physical dimensions required for these structures.
Radio antennas radiate electromagnetic waves that can reach the receiver either by ground-wave propagation or by refraction from the ionosphere, known as sky-wave propagation. The ground-wave component is the portion of the radiated electromagnetic wave that propagates close to the earth's surface. It has both direct-wave and ground-reflected components, and under certain conditions a tropospheric ducting component. The direct-wave is limited only by the distance from the transmitter to the horizon plus a small distance added by atmospheric diffraction around the curvature of the earth. The ground-reflected portion of the radiated wave reaches the receiving antenna after being reflected from the earth's surface. A portion of the ground-wave energy radiated by the antenna may also be guided by the earth's surface as a ground-hugging surface wave.]"
Why AM Radio Stations Must Reduce Power, Change Operations, or Cease Operations at Night". fcc.gov.
Nikola Tesla's rights to radio were based upon these patents:
- Division of "System of Transmission of Electrical Energy", March 20, 1900 (March 20, 1900; filed Sept. 2, 1897). In US645576, Tesla cited the well-known radiant energy phenomena and corrected previous errors in theory of behavior. Within this specification, Tesla declared, "The apparatus which I have shown will obviously have many other valuable uses - as, for instance, when it is desired to transmit intelligible messages to great distances ".
- , "Apparatus for Transmission of Electrical Energy" (May 15, 1900; filed February 19, 1900). In US649621, Tesla established a system which was composed of a transmitting coil (or conductor) arranged and excited to cause oscillations (or currents) to propagate via Electrical conduction through the natural medium from one point to another remote point therefrom and a receiver coil, or conductor, of the transmitted signals.
Shortly after the turn of the 20th century, the US Patent Office also awarded Marconi a patent for radio.
Priority in the invention of radio
Tesla’s pioneering contribution to radio technology was a reworking of the primitive Hertz spark-gap transmitter; introduction of the coupled tuned circuit with the energy storage capacitor and discharger repositioned to the primary side of the transformer. "Tesla Coils — An RF Power Processing Tutorial for Engineers", Kenneth L. Corum and James F. Corum This is the classic Tesla coil configuration, with primary and secondary circuits tuned to vibrate in harmony. These modifications allowed significantly higher levels of radio-frequency energy to be concentrated into a damped or partially damped wave, and ultimately a practically undamped wave. Some historians credit
Reginald Fessenden in 1900 for making these improvements. Others credit Adolph Slaby. Still others say it was Ferdinand Braun, in a hastily improvised demonstration performed in September 1898. Braun, together with Marconi, received the Nobel Prize in physics for this replication of Tesla’s discovery.
Actually, it was Nikola Tesla who first revealed the basic techniques for improving transmitter performance. He did this in a series of U.S. patents, starting with his "System of Electric Lighting", Patent No. 454,622, dated
June 23,
1891, the accompanying drawing of which clearly shows an energy storage capacitor and a discharge device on the primary side of a resonance transformer. In1893 at a public meeting of the National Electric Light Association in St. Louis, this radio-frequency power supply circuit was used to demonstrate the world's first practical radio transmitter.
His patent "Means for Generating Electric Currents" No. 514,168 of
February 6,
1894 describes a variation of the 1891 circuit. Between September 15, 1896 and November 18,
1898, 17 patents were granted to Tesla for apparatus and methods directly related to the production of high power radio-frequency electrical currents.
On
2 September 1897 Tesla filed his first application which was directly related to wireless transmission and reception, resulting in two patents that were subsequently issued as "System of . . ." and "Apparatus for Transmission of Electrical Energy", dated March 20 and
May 15,
1900 respectively.
On July 1, 1898 another wireless-related application was filed for the radio-controlled boat resulting in the patent, "Method of and Apparatus for Controlling Mechanism of Moving Vessels or Vehicles" issued
November 8, 1898. He also developed receivers incorporating two tuned circuits. Between 1898 and 1903 Tesla received 10 U.S. patents covering his work in this area.
In 1904 Marconi got his own patent, declaring principles that Tesla had developed. The issue of patent infringement by Marconi was addressed in a lawsuit brought by Tesla in 1915. Nothing significant resulted from this litigation and shortly thereafter the Marconi Wireless Telegraph Company of America itself sued the United States for alleged damages resulting from the use of wireless during World War I. In response, a 1935 ruling by the United States Court of Claims essentially invalidated the fundamental Marconi patent. It was decided that the basic apparatus associated with radio communications had, in fact, been anticipated by Tesla. The U.S. Supreme Court affirmed this finding on June 21, 1943. The following definition of radio emerged as a result of this case:
A radio communication system requires two tuned circuits each at the transmitter and receiver, all four tuned to the same frequency. Wireless Telegraphy Company vs. United States
de Moura's work
Landell de Moura, the end of the 1800s, established the pioneering radio transmission in the
Southern Hemisphere. His experiment consisted of a transmitter located in
São Paulo and a receiver in its suburbs were eight kilometers apart. By his actions, wireless communications commenced in southeastern Brazil and South America.http://www.comsoc.org/dl/gcn/gcn0300.html The transmission of voice reportedly took place in 1893, two years after Tesla began his research. On
June 3, 1900, there were public demonstrations a radio broadcast of the human voice. The device de Moura was protected later by Brazilian patent number 3279 which was granted on March 9,
1901. He would later acquire United States patents for a transmitter in , for a wireless phone in , and for a wireless telegraph in .
Popov's work
Beginning in the early 1890s, Alexander Stepanovich Popov conducted experiments along the lines of Hertz's research. In 1894 he built his first
radio receiver, which contained a
coherer. Further refined as a lightning detector, he presented it to the Russian Physical and Chemical Society on May 7,
1895 — the day has been celebrated in the Russian Federation as "Radio Day". The paper on his findings was published the same year (
December 15 1895). Popov had recorded, at the end of 1895, that he was hoping for distant signalling with radio waves. D.T. Emerson, " The work of Jagadis Chandra Bose: 100 years of mm-wave research". National Radio Astronomy Observatory, February 1998. In 1900, Popov stated (in front of the Congress of Russian Electrical Engineers),
"
the emission and reception of signals by Marconi by means of electric oscillations nothing new. In America, the famous engineer Nikola Tesla carried the same experiments in 1893.""
The Guglielmo Marconi Case; Who is the True Inventor of Radio".
Bose's work
in his lab.
In November 1894, the
Bengali people Undivided India physicist,
Jagdish Chandra Bose, demonstrated publicly the use of radio waves in
Kolkata, but he was not interested in patenting his work." Jagadish Chandra Bose". ieee-virtual-museum.org. For more information see History of radio (more information)#Jagdish Chandra Bose. In 1894, Bose ignited
gunpowder and rang a bell at a distance using
electromagnetic waves, showing independently that communication signals can be sent without using wires. In 1896, the
Daily Chronicle of England reported on his UHF experiments: "
The inventor (J.C. Bose) has transmitted signals to a distance of nearly a mile and herein lies the first and obvious and exceedingly valuable application of this new theoretical marvel." The 1895 public demonstration by Bose in Calcutta was before Marconi's wireless signalling experiment on
Salisbury Plain in England in May 1897."
The Work of Jagdish Chandra Bose: 100 years of mm-wave research". tuc.nrao.edu."
Jagadish Chandra Bose", ieee-virtual-museum.org. Though Bose did this demonstration, Tesla had performed radio communication earlier in 1892 and 1893.
Bose was not interested in the commercial applications of the experiment's transmitter. He did not try to file
patent protection for sending signals. In 1899, Bose announced the development of a "
iron-mercury-iron coherer with telephone detector" in a paper presented at the Royal Society, London.Bondyopadhyay, Probir K., "
Sir J. C. Bose's Diode Detector Received Marconi's First Transatlantic Wireless Signal Of December 1901 (The "Italian Navy Coherer" Scandal Revisited)". Proc. IEEE, Vol. 86, No. 1, January 1988. Later he received , "
Detector for electrical distrubances" (1904), for a specific electromagnetic receiver. Though he did not file any patents for transmission, he is recognized for contributing to the development of radio.
Marconi's work
Early years
Guglielmo Marconi's proponents say that while on vacation in 1894 he read about the experiments that Hertz did in the 1880s, and about Nikola Tesla's work in the just-published book
Inventions, Researches and Writings of Nikola Tesla. It was at this time that Marconi began to understand that radio waves could be used for wireless communications.Henry M. Bradford, "
Marconi's Three; Transatlantic Radio Stations In Cape Breton". Read before the Royal Nova Scotia Historical Society, 31 January 1996. (
ed. the site is reproduced with permission from the
Royal Nova Scotia Historical Society Journal, Volume 1, 1998.)
Marconi's early apparatus was a development of Hertz’s laboratory apparatus into a system designed for communications purposes. At first he used a transmitter to ring a bell in a receiver in his attic laboratory. He then moved his experiments out-of-doors on the family estate near
Bologna, Italy, to communicate further. He replaced Hertz’s vertical dipole with a vertical wire topped by a metal sheet, with an opposing terminal connected to the ground. On the receiver side, Marconi replaced the spark gap with a metal powder
coherer, a detector developed by Edouard Branly and other experimenters. Marconi transmitted radio signals for about a mile at the end of 1895.
Marconi's Three; Transatlantic Radio Stations In Cape Breton.
Marconi's reputation is largely based on these accomplishments in radio communications and commercializing a practical system. His demonstrations of the use of radio for wireless communications, equipping ships with life saving wireless communications, establishing the first transatlantic radio service, and building the first stations for the British short wave service, have marked his place in history. Marconi and his company were not alone in the field; his principal competition came from German scientists whose work would become the basis for the Telefunken company (which Nikola Tesla assisted in building).
Marconi's (
July 13, 1897) (and the reissued ) disclosed a two-circuit system for the transmission and reception of "Hertzian waves" (though he would later acknowledge that in the early wireless systems the "
waves do not propagate in the same manner as free radiation from a classical Hertzian oscillator, but surface wave"Marconi, "
Wireless Telegraphic Communication: Nobel Lecture, December 11, 1909." Nobel Lectures. Physics 1901-1921. Amsterdam: Elsevier Publishing Company, 1967: 196-222.). The transmitter was an antenna circuit, with an aerial plate and a ground plate, and a spark gap. Induced signals in the circuit were caused to discharge through a spark gap, producing oscillations which were radiated. The receiver contained an antenna circuit, an aerial plate and a ground plate, and a
coherer. Marconi's apparatus was to be resonant (commonly called by various researcheres at the time syntonic). This was done by the careful determination of the size of the aerial plates.
The Poldhu experiment
In 1901, Marconi claimed to have received daytime transatlantic radio frequency signals at a
medium frequency (820 kHz).Henry M. Bradford, "
Marconi in Newfoundland: The 1901 Transatlantic Radio Experiment".Henry M. Bradford, "
Did Marconi Receive Transatlantic Radio Signals in 1901? - Part 1". Wolfville, N.S..Henry M. Bradford, "
Did Marconi Receive Transatlantic Radio Signals in 1901? Part 2, Conclusion: The Trans-Atlantic Experiments". Wolfville, N.S.. The early spark transmitters
may have been broadly tuned and the Poldhu transmitter
may have radiated sufficient energy in that part of the spectrum for a transatlantic transmission,
if Marconi was using an untuned receiver when he claimed to have received the transatlantic signal at Newfoundland in 1901. When he used a tuned receiver aboard the SS Philadelphia in 1902, he could only receive a daytime signal from Poldhu, a distance of 700 miles,
less than half the distance from Poldhu to Newfoundland. At night the signals were reported to have been received several times further, and his successful transatlantic transmissions from Glace Bay, Nova Scotia in 1902 were made at night. Marconi would later found the Marconi Company and would jointly receive the 1909
Nobel Prize in Physics with
Karl Ferdinand Braun.
Marconi’s 1901
Poldhu to
Colony of Newfoundland transmission claim has been attacked.John S. Belrose, "
Fessenden and Marconi; Their Differing Technologies and Transatlantic Experiments During the First Decade of this Century", International Conference on 100 Years of Radio, 5-7 September, 1995, (PDF file;
ed. accessed April 14, 2006) Critics have claimed that it is more likely that Marconi received
Signal noise from
atmospheric electricity in the 1901 experiment. "Marconi's Error: The First Transatlantic Wireless Telegraphy in 1901" The transmitting station in Poldhu, Cornwall used a spark-gap transmitter that could produce a signal just below the medium frequency and with high power levels (a maximum time-averaged power of 35 kilowatts, but with a peak pulse power of megawatts). The message received was the morse letter 'S' - three dots. Dr Jack Belrose has recently contested this, however, based on theoretical work as well as a reenactment of the experiment; he believes that Marconi heard only random atmospheric noise and mistook it for the signal. There are various science historians who agree with Jack Belrose (in addition to being bolstered by Tesla supporters) that the Atlantic was not bridged in 1901, but other science historians have taken the position that this was the first trans-atlantic radio transmission.
Court decision
In 1943 a lawsuit regarding Marconi's numerous other radio patents was resolved by the U.S. Supreme Court, who overturned most of these. At the time, the
United States Army was involved in a patent infringement lawsuit with Marconi's company regarding radio, leading various observers to posit that the government nullified Marconi's other patents in order to moot any claims for compensation (as, it is speculated, the government's initial reversal to grant Marconi the patent right in order to nullify any claims Tesla had for compensation).
The court decision was based on the proven prior work conducted by others, such as by Tesla,
Oliver Lodge, and
John Stone Stone, from which some of Marconi patents (such as ) stemmed. The U. S. Supreme Court stated that,
"
The Tesla patent No. 645,576, applied for September 2, 1897 and allowed March 20, 1900, disclosed a four-circuit system, having two circuits each at transmitter and receiver, and recommended that all four circuits be tuned to the same frequency. He
recognized that his apparatus could, without change, be used for wireless communication, which is dependent upon the transmission of electrical energy."U.S. Supreme Court, "
Marconi Wireless Telegraph co. of America v. United States". 320 U.S. 1. Nos. 369, 373. Argued April 9-12, 1943. Decided June 21,
1943.
In making their decision, the court noted,
"
Marconi's reputation as the man who first achieved successful radio transmission rests on his original patent, which became reissue No. 11,913, and which is not here U.S. 1, 38 in question. That reputation, however well-deserved, does not entitle him to a patent for every later improvement which he claims in the radio field. Patent cases, like others, must be decided not by weighing the reputations of the litigations, but by careful study of the merits of their respective contentions and proofs."
Wireless Telegraph co. of America v. United States.
The court also stated that,
"
It is well established that as between two inventors priority of invention will be awarded to the one who by satisfying proof can show that he first conceived of the invention."
Wireless Telegraph co. of America v. United States.
Case of priority
Case for Marconi
Marconi supporters have stated that Marconi was not aware of the works of Nikola Tesla in the United States. It is unlikely, though, that Marconi was unaware of Tesla's presentations. Both
On Light and Other High Frequency Phenomena (Philadelphia/St. Louis; Franklin Institute in 1893) and
Experiments with Alternating Currents of High Potential and High Frequency (London; 1892) were reported on internationally. Tesla's 1893 presentation at the Franklin Institute was reported across America (such as in
The Century Magazine) and throughout Europe.Ljubo Vujovi, "
Tesla Biography; Nikola Tesla, The genius who lit the world". Teslasociety.com. Tesla also performed public demonstrations of actual and related work, such as the remote-controlled boat in 1898 (which was protected under ). The remote-controlled boat contained "rotating
coherers" that allowed secure communication between transmitter and receiver.
Case against Marconi
By 1895, Marconi introduced to the public a device in
London, asserting it was his invention. Despite Marconi's statements to the contrary, though, the apparatus resembles Tesla's descriptions in the widely translated articles. P.J.Papadopoulos, " Nikola Tesla; The Guglielmo Marconi Case, Who is the True Inventor of Radio?" Marconi's later practical four-tuned system was pre-dated by N. Tesla,
History of radio#Oliver Lodge, and J. S. Stone. Tesla was the first, though, to expound the principles of the four-tuned system. The earlier two-tuned systems were not practical for commercial activity (as found in the United States court case). In addition, other prior work was conducted by others (such as by Hertz and Bruan, but not excluding others) from which many of Marconi's devices and methods were derived. Marconi's
Apparatus for wireless telegraphy , in which a more intricate system was disclosed than in his earlier patents, was filed after contributions made by other investigators. Marconi’s late-1895 transmission of signals was for around a mile. This was small when put against Tesla's early-1895 transmissions of up to 50 miles.
Case for Tesla
Nikola Tesla was first to hold the rights to radio:
- , "System of Transmission of Electrical Energy", March 20, 1900 (March 20, 1900; filed Sept. 2, 1897).
- , "Apparatus for Transmission of Electrical Energy" (May 15, 1900; filed February 19, 1900).
Tesla's system can produce a variety of wave propagations, pending the driving apparatus. Tesla believed that his wireless system would be better than most other radio systems because Transverse wave (whose behavior depends on their wavelength) would decay as they travelled from the transmitter, making the signals uselessly weak at long distances. Tesla advanced that Longitudinal wave (such as those that occur in waves in plasmas) through the medium would be used, as he theorized that they would be practically lossless. His devices can be driven to produce either transverse or longitudinal waves.
There is also the relevance of Tesla demonstrations of the remote-controlled boat (with its internal rotating coherer) as well as Tesla's public lecture demonstrations. Besides his intention to transmit wireless signals of intelligence, he proposed to transmit
electric power via electrical conduction through the earth and the upper atmosphere, as well as in between them both (in the earth-ionosphere region which is now known as a
cavity resonator). This power transmission was to be done not by "hertzian waves," but through
standing wave surface waves. Tesla’s proposed wireless transmitter utilized a resonant transformer to apply a very high voltage of high frequency between the earth and a large elevated conductor, as discussed earlier.
Case against Tesla
Tesla never completed his "worldwide wireless system," primarily because of financial difficulties. Cost overruns stopped him from completing the Wardenclyffe Tower (a "wireless station tower") that he built in the early 1900s in
Shoreham, New York on Long Island, New York.
Timeline
The identity of the original inventor of radio, at the time called wireless telegraphy, is contentious. The key invention for the beginning of "wireless transmission of data using the entire frequency spectrum" has been attributed to various inventors and researchers. Below is a chart of important events and individuals related to the development of radio.ImageSize = width:777 height:633DateFormat = YYYYPeriod = from:1860 till:1960PlotArea = width:665 height:600 left:33 bottom:25TimeAxis = orientation:vertical order:reverseScaleMajor = unit:year increment:10 start:1860ScaleMinor = unit:year increment:1 start:1860PlotData= at:1864 fontsize:S text:"[James Clerk Maxwell predicts electromagnetic (EM) waves using a transmission medium.
at:1872 fontsize:S text:"[Mahlon Loomis and W. H. Ward (USA) file for U.S. Patents for a "wireless telegraph"."
at:1878 fontsize:S text:"[David Edward Hughes transcieves via induction transmission."
at:1885 fontsize:S text:"[Thomas Alva Edison uses a vibrator magnet for induction transmission. [Heinrich Rudolf Hertz begins EM wave experiments".
at:1887 fontsize:S text:"[Heinrich Rudolf Hertz publishes his research in the journal Annalen der Physik. Edison installs signalling syetem at the Lehigh Valley Railroad."
at:1891 fontsize:S text:"[Nikola Tesla is granted U.S. Patents No. 447,920, and 447,921 (VLF generators) and 454,622 (RF power supply). Edison receives U. S. Patent No. 465971.
at:1893 fontsize:S text:"Tesla demonstrates wireless techniques at the Franklin Institute in Philadelphia."
at:1895 text:"[Alexander Stepanovich Popov presents his radio receiver to the Russian Physical and Chemical Society."
at:1897 fontsize:S text:"[Guglielmo Marconi is granted British patent No. 12,039 (Radio patent). Tesla is granted U.S. Patents No. 645,576 and 649,621 (Four-tuned circuit patents)."
at:1901 fontsize:S text:"[Wardenclyffe Tower is opened by Tesla. Marconi receives British patent No. 7,777 and reports transatlantic transmission."
at:1904 fontsize:S text:"[John Ambrose Fleming develops the "oscillation valve" (vacuum-tube diode). "
at:1906 fontsize:S text:"[Lee De Forest invents the [Audion tube, now known as the vacuum-tube [triode."
at:1909 fontsize:S text:"[Karl Ferdinand Braun and Marconi receive Nobel Prize in physics, 'in recognition of their contributions to the development of wireless telegraphy'."
at:1922 fontsize:S text:"[BBC begins broadcasting from London."
at:1928 fontsize:S text:"[Julius Edgar Lilienfeld patents the transistor principle in Germany"
at:1933 fontsize:S text:"[Edwin Howard Armstrong patents FM ([frequency modulation)"
at:1943 fontsize:S text:"Marconi's radio patents in the United States overturned due to prior art."
at:1947 fontsize:S text:"[William Shockley, [John Bardeen and [Walter Brattain build the [transistor."
at:1956 fontsize:S text:"Shockley, Bardeen and Brattain receive the Nobel Prize in Physics for the invention of the transistor."
See also
Notes
References
- "Marconi Wireless Telegraphy Company of America v United States", 320 U.S. 1. Nos. 369, 373. Argued April 9-12, 1943. Decided June 21, 1943 http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/printer_friendly.pl?page=us/320/1.html
- Anderson, L.I., "Priority in the Invention of Radio: Tesla vs. Marconi", Antique Wireless Association Monograph No. 4, March, 1980.
- Anderson, L.I., "John Stone Stone on Nikola Tesla's Priority in Radio and Continuous-Wave Radiofrequency Apparatus", The A.W.A. (Antique Wireless Association) Review, Vol. 1, 1986, pp. 18-41.
- Wunsch, A.D., "Misreading the Supreme Court,” Antenna, Volume 11 No. 1, November 1998, Society for the History of Technology http://www.mercurians.org/nov98/misreading.html
- Brand, W.E., "Rereading the Supreme Court: Tesla's Invention of Radio", Antenna, Volume 11 No. 2, May 1998, Society for the History of Technology http://www.mercurians.org/may99/rereading.html
This article covers the main arguments about who had what part in the early development of radio.
For the general history of radio, see History of radio.
Within the
timeline of radio, many people were involved in the
invention of radio transmission of information as we know it today. Despite this, during its early development and long after wide acceptance, disputes persisted as to who could claim sole credit for this obvious boon to mankind.
Early wireless work
Scientific theory and verification
James Clerk Maxwell performed the theoretical physical research that correctly predicted the existence of radio (and all other electromagnetic) waves. Heinrich Rudolf Hertz was the experimental physicist who created radio waves in a controlled laboratory manner. Neither Maxwell nor Hertz, though, devised systems for actual general use or described the application of the technology.
Developments, parallel to these individuals and after, are engineering investigations that lead to the '
invention of radio': the objects, processes, or techniques of information transception. Many individuals contributed to the art of
wireless, in the air, earth, and water; this includes the precursory work in wireless telephony and wireless telegraphy.
SLF and UHF experimentation
David E. Hughes, eight years before Hertz's experiments and nearly two decades before Guglielmo Marconi demonstrations, induced electromagnetic waves in a signalling system. Hughes transmitted Morse code by an
Electromagnetic induction apparatus. In 1878, Hughes's induction transmission method utilized a "clockwork transmitter" to transmit signals. In 1885, Thomas Alva Edison used a vibrator magnet for induction transmission. In 1888, Edison deployed a system of signalling on the Lehigh Valley Railroad. In 1891, Edison attained the wireless patent for this method using inductance ().
From 1886 to 1888 inclusive in his classic
Ultra high frequency experiments, Heinrich Rudolf Hertz had proved that the properties of radio waves were consistent with Maxwell’s electromagnetic theory. He demonstrated that radio radiation had all the properties of waves (now called Transverse waves), and discovered that the electromagnetic equations could be reformulated into a
partial differential equation called the wave equation.
Of the three basic forms of wireless aerial launching structures, the Hertz antenna was a center-fed half-
wavelength dipole antenna (with the other forms being the
Marconi antenna and
Tesla antenna). Hertz’s setup for a source and detector of radio waves (archaically called
Hertz waves in his honor) comprised a primitive radio system capable of transmitting and receiving
space waves through
free space. Hertz wave His transmitter was not at all efficient and was severely limited in power output. Its dipole antenna differed from the vertical quarter-wavelength antenna that was subsequently adopted by Marconi and others in that it was not grounded. Peterson, Gary, "
Comparing the Hertz-wave and Tesla wireless systems". Feed Line No. 9 Article
Hertz used the damped oscillating currents in a dipole antenna, triggered by a high-voltage electrical capacitive spark discharge, as his source of radio waves. His detector in some experiments was another dipole antenna connected to a narrow spark gap. A small spark in this gap signified detection of the radio wave. When he added cylindrical reflectors behind his dipole antennas, Hertz could detect radio waves about 20 metres from the transmitter in his
laboratory. He did not try to transmit further because he wanted to prove
Electromagnetism theory, not to develop wireless
communications.
Hertz seemed uninterested in the practical importance of his experiments. He stated that "
It's of no use whatsoever ... this is just an experiment that proves Maestro James Clerk Maxwell was right - we just have these mysterious electromagnetic waves that we cannot see with the naked eye. But they are there." Eugenii Katz, "
Heinrich Rudolf Hertz". Biographies of Famous Electrochemists and Physicists Contributed to Understanding of Electricity, Biosensors & Bioelectronics.Asked about the ramifications of his discoveries, Hertz replied, "
Nothing, I guess." Hertz also stated, "I do not think that the wireless waves I have discovered will have any practical application." Hertz died in 1894, so the art of radio was left to others to implement into a practical useful form. His discoveries would later be taken up by entrepreneurs looking to make their fortunes. Marconi's 1895 experiments followed Hertz's work (among others) by using a spark source in what became known as a
spark-gap transmitter.
Tesla's work
: Serbian/Croatian/Austro-Hungarian/American inventor, physicist, mechanical engineer and electrical engineer who some people regard as one of the most important inventors in history.
Radio frequency generation
Nikola Tesla was one of the first to patent a means to reliably produce radio frequency currents. Tesla's , "
Method of Operating Arc-Lamps" (
March 10,
1891), describes an alternator that produced high-frequency current (for that time period), around 10,000 cycles per second. (The term cycles-per-second was later modified to "
hertz.") His
patentable innovation was suppression of the sound produced by arc lamps that were operated on alternating or pulsating current by using frequencies beyond the range of human hearing. The alternator produced frequencies in the Very Low Frequency (VLF) band.
Continued research and patents
Around July 1891, he established his
New York laboratory and constructed various apparatuses that produced between 15,000 to 18,000 cycles per second. At this location, he also lit vacuum tubes wirelessly (thus providing hard evidence for the potential of wireless transmissions). Transmission and radiation of radio frequency energy was a feature exhibited in the experiments by Tesla and was noted early on to be used for the
telecommunication of
information."
On Light and Other High Frequency Phenomena". Delivered before the Franklin Institute, Philadelphia, February 1893, and before the National Electric Light Association, St. Louis, March 1893."
Experiments with Alternating Currents of High Potential and High Frequency". Delivered before the Institution of Electrical Engineers, London, February 1892.
In 1892, Tesla delivered a widely reported presentation before the
Institution of Electrical Engineers of London in which he noted, among other things, that intelligence would be transmitted without wires. Later, a variety of Tesla's radio frequency systems were demonstrated during another widely known lecture, presented to meetings of the National Electric Light Association in St. Louis, Missouri and the
Franklin Institute in Philadelphia. According to the
IEEE, "
the apparatus that he employed contained all the elements of spark and continuous wave that were incorporated into radio"."
Nikola Tesla, 1856 - 1943". IEEE History Center, IEEE, 2003.
In late 1896 or early 1897 Tesla received wireless signals transmitted from the Houston St. lab in New York City to West Point, New York, "a distance of about 30 miles." The transmitter consisted of an RF alternator and produced
Continuous wave Low frequency. The receiver consisted of a powerful electromagnet, two large condensers, and a taut steel wire. The wire was placed within the magnetic field, and in conjunction with the condensers formed a tuned circuit."Nikola Tesla On His Work with Alternating Currents and Their Application to wireless Telegraphy, Telephony, and Transmission of Power", Leland I. Anderson, Twenty First Century Books, 2002, pp. 26-27.]PBS: Marconi and Tesla: Who invented radio? In 1899 Tesla established an "Experimental Station" in Colorado Springs where he continued his research into wireless transmission principles often using a form of electrical oscillator known as the magnifying transmitter.
.Early on in his research Tesla used his high voltage resonance transformer—the Tesla coil—in radio-wave propagation experiments. The
Antenna (radio)#Antenna parameters consisted of a top-loaded electrical conductor that was connected to a high-voltage terminal of the transformer. The opposing high-voltage terminal was grounded. The secondary winding was driven by a primary circuit consisting of a few turns of heavy wire, a capacitor bank, a circuit controller, and a power supply transformer. The launching structure radiated as a common "Hertz wave" antenna. In Tesla's own words,"The popular impression is that my wireless work was begun in 1893, but as a matter of fact I spent the two preceding years in investigations, employing forms of apparatus, some of which were almost like those of today. . . .""
The True Wireless"After a while he began to favor another technique that he called the “disturbed charge of ground and air method.” Tesla's wireless system used the same basic apparatus, however instead of using electromagnetic space waves the energy is carried by the conduction of electrical currents through the earth and along with accompanying surface waves. In one form of the system the ‘return’ path closing the circuit is an electrical current flow established between two elevated terminals, one belonging to the transmitter and the other the receiver. These consist of conduction currents flowing through plasma and also electrostatic induction. Once again in Tesla's own words,". . . It was clear to me from the very start that the successful consummation could only be brought about by a number of radical improvements. Suitable high frequency generators and electrical oscillators had first to be produced. The energy of these had to be transformed in effective transmitters and collected at a distance in proper receivers. Such a system would be manifestly circumscribed in its usefulness if all extraneous interference were not prevented and exclusiveness secured. In time, however, I recognized that devices of this kind, to be most effective and efficient, should be designed with due regard to the physical properties of this planet and the electrical conditions obtaining on the same. . . .""
ibid"In other words, Tesla’s structure injected a large alternating current into the earth via the ground terminal. Tesla's discovery of importance was the "Surface wave" method. The production of surface waves as described by Arnold Sommerfeld and Jonathan Zenneck was partially the consequence of adding a deep ground connection to the transmitter. Tesla said in 1893 that "
One of the terminals of the source would be connected to Earth a
Ground (electricity) ...]
the other to an insulated body of large surface."
On Light and Other High Frequency Phenomena". Delivered before the Franklin Institute, Philadelphia, February 1893, and before the National Electric Light Association, St. Louis, March 1893.
A shallow buried ground plane or an elevated insulated counterpoise is commonly used in the construction of low and medium frequency 1/4-wavelength radio antennas. These lend to the development of the Norton Surface Wave. This method led to longer transmission ranges. Many AM stations use this same principle to boost reception of their signals."
Why AM Radio Stations Must Reduce Power, Change Operations, or Cease Operations at Night". fcc.gov. This also allow modern grounded AM 1/4 wavelength monopole antenna to be more practical in order to overcome the restrictions imposed upon designers by the large physical dimensions required for these structures.
Radio antennas radiate electromagnetic waves that can reach the receiver either by ground-wave propagation or by refraction from the ionosphere, known as sky-wave propagation. The ground-wave component is the portion of the radiated electromagnetic wave that propagates close to the earth's surface. It has both direct-wave and ground-reflected components, and under certain conditions a tropospheric ducting component. The direct-wave is limited only by the distance from the transmitter to the horizon plus a small distance added by atmospheric diffraction around the curvature of the earth. The ground-reflected portion of the radiated wave reaches the receiving antenna after being reflected from the earth's surface. A portion of the ground-wave energy radiated by the antenna may also be guided by the earth's surface as a ground-hugging surface wave.]"
Why AM Radio Stations Must Reduce Power, Change Operations, or Cease Operations at Night". fcc.gov.
Nikola Tesla's rights to radio were based upon these patents:
- Division of "System of Transmission of Electrical Energy", March 20, 1900 (March 20, 1900; filed Sept. 2, 1897). In US645576, Tesla cited the well-known radiant energy phenomena and corrected previous errors in theory of behavior. Within this specification, Tesla declared, "The apparatus which I have shown will obviously have many other valuable uses - as, for instance, when it is desired to transmit intelligible messages to great distances ".
- , "Apparatus for Transmission of Electrical Energy" (May 15, 1900; filed February 19, 1900). In US649621, Tesla established a system which was composed of a transmitting coil (or conductor) arranged and excited to cause oscillations (or currents) to propagate via Electrical conduction through the natural medium from one point to another remote point therefrom and a receiver coil, or conductor, of the transmitted signals.
Shortly after the turn of the 20th century, the US Patent Office also awarded Marconi a patent for radio.
Priority in the invention of radio
Tesla’s pioneering contribution to radio technology was a reworking of the primitive Hertz spark-gap transmitter; introduction of the coupled tuned circuit with the energy storage capacitor and discharger repositioned to the primary side of the transformer. "Tesla Coils — An RF Power Processing Tutorial for Engineers", Kenneth L. Corum and James F. Corum This is the classic Tesla coil configuration, with primary and secondary circuits tuned to vibrate in harmony. These modifications allowed significantly higher levels of radio-frequency energy to be concentrated into a damped or partially damped wave, and ultimately a practically undamped wave. Some historians credit Reginald Fessenden in 1900 for making these improvements. Others credit Adolph Slaby. Still others say it was Ferdinand Braun, in a hastily improvised demonstration performed in September 1898. Braun, together with Marconi, received the Nobel Prize in physics for this replication of Tesla’s discovery.
Actually, it was Nikola Tesla who first revealed the basic techniques for improving transmitter performance. He did this in a series of U.S. patents, starting with his "System of Electric Lighting", Patent No. 454,622, dated
June 23,
1891, the accompanying drawing of which clearly shows an energy storage capacitor and a discharge device on the primary side of a resonance transformer. In1893 at a public meeting of the National Electric Light Association in St. Louis, this radio-frequency power supply circuit was used to demonstrate the world's first practical radio transmitter.
His patent "Means for Generating Electric Currents" No. 514,168 of February 6,
1894 describes a variation of the 1891 circuit. Between September 15, 1896 and
November 18,
1898, 17 patents were granted to Tesla for apparatus and methods directly related to the production of high power radio-frequency electrical currents.
On
2 September 1897 Tesla filed his first application which was directly related to wireless transmission and reception, resulting in two patents that were subsequently issued as "System of . . ." and "Apparatus for Transmission of Electrical Energy", dated March 20 and
May 15,
1900 respectively.
On
July 1, 1898 another wireless-related application was filed for the radio-controlled boat resulting in the patent, "Method of and Apparatus for Controlling Mechanism of Moving Vessels or Vehicles" issued November 8, 1898. He also developed receivers incorporating two tuned circuits. Between 1898 and 1903 Tesla received 10 U.S. patents covering his work in this area.
In 1904 Marconi got his own patent, declaring principles that Tesla had developed. The issue of patent infringement by Marconi was addressed in a lawsuit brought by Tesla in 1915. Nothing significant resulted from this litigation and shortly thereafter the Marconi Wireless Telegraph Company of America itself sued the United States for alleged damages resulting from the use of wireless during World War I. In response, a 1935 ruling by the United States Court of Claims essentially invalidated the fundamental Marconi patent. It was decided that the basic apparatus associated with radio communications had, in fact, been anticipated by Tesla. The U.S. Supreme Court affirmed this finding on June 21, 1943. The following definition of radio emerged as a result of this case:
A radio communication system requires two tuned circuits each at the transmitter and receiver, all four tuned to the same frequency. Wireless Telegraphy Company vs. United States
de Moura's work
Landell de Moura, the end of the 1800s, established the pioneering radio transmission in the Southern Hemisphere. His experiment consisted of a transmitter located in São Paulo and a receiver in its suburbs were eight kilometers apart. By his actions, wireless communications commenced in southeastern Brazil and South America.http://www.comsoc.org/dl/gcn/gcn0300.html The transmission of voice reportedly took place in 1893, two years after Tesla began his research. On June 3, 1900, there were public demonstrations a radio broadcast of the human voice. The device de Moura was protected later by Brazilian patent number 3279 which was granted on March 9, 1901. He would later acquire United States patents for a transmitter in , for a wireless phone in , and for a wireless telegraph in .
Popov's work
Beginning in the early 1890s, Alexander Stepanovich Popov conducted experiments along the lines of Hertz's research. In 1894 he built his first radio receiver, which contained a
coherer. Further refined as a
lightning detector, he presented it to the Russian Physical and Chemical Society on May 7, 1895 — the day has been celebrated in the Russian Federation as "
Radio Day". The paper on his findings was published the same year (
December 15 1895). Popov had recorded, at the end of 1895, that he was hoping for distant signalling with radio waves. D.T. Emerson, " The work of Jagadis Chandra Bose: 100 years of mm-wave research". National Radio Astronomy Observatory, February 1998. In 1900, Popov stated (in front of the Congress of Russian Electrical Engineers),
"
the emission and reception of signals by Marconi by means of electric oscillations nothing new. In America, the famous engineer Nikola Tesla carried the same experiments in 1893.""
The Guglielmo Marconi Case; Who is the True Inventor of Radio".
Bose's work
in his lab.
In November 1894, the Bengali people Undivided India physicist,
Jagdish Chandra Bose, demonstrated publicly the use of radio waves in
Kolkata, but he was not interested in patenting his work." Jagadish Chandra Bose". ieee-virtual-museum.org. For more information see History of radio (more information)#Jagdish Chandra Bose. In 1894, Bose ignited
gunpowder and rang a bell at a distance using
electromagnetic waves, showing independently that communication signals can be sent without using wires. In 1896, the Daily Chronicle of England reported on his UHF experiments: "
The inventor (J.C. Bose) has transmitted signals to a distance of nearly a mile and herein lies the first and obvious and exceedingly valuable application of this new theoretical marvel." The 1895 public demonstration by Bose in Calcutta was before Marconi's wireless signalling experiment on
Salisbury Plain in England in May 1897."
The Work of Jagdish Chandra Bose: 100 years of mm-wave research". tuc.nrao.edu."
Jagadish Chandra Bose", ieee-virtual-museum.org. Though Bose did this demonstration, Tesla had performed radio communication earlier in 1892 and 1893.
Bose was not interested in the commercial applications of the experiment's transmitter. He did not try to file
patent protection for sending signals. In 1899, Bose announced the development of a "
iron-mercury-iron coherer with telephone detector" in a paper presented at the Royal Society, London.Bondyopadhyay, Probir K., "
Sir J. C. Bose's Diode Detector Received Marconi's First Transatlantic Wireless Signal Of December 1901 (The "Italian Navy Coherer" Scandal Revisited)". Proc. IEEE, Vol. 86, No. 1, January 1988. Later he received , "
Detector for electrical distrubances" (1904), for a specific electromagnetic receiver. Though he did not file any patents for transmission, he is recognized for contributing to the development of radio.
Marconi's work
Early years
Guglielmo Marconi's proponents say that while on vacation in 1894 he read about the experiments that Hertz did in the 1880s, and about Nikola Tesla's work in the just-published book
Inventions, Researches and Writings of Nikola Tesla. It was at this time that Marconi began to understand that radio waves could be used for wireless communications.Henry M. Bradford, "
Marconi's Three; Transatlantic Radio Stations In Cape Breton". Read before the Royal
Nova Scotia Historical Society,
31 January 1996. (
ed. the site is reproduced with permission from the
Royal Nova Scotia Historical Society Journal, Volume 1, 1998.)
Marconi's early apparatus was a development of Hertz’s laboratory apparatus into a system designed for communications purposes. At first he used a transmitter to ring a bell in a receiver in his attic laboratory. He then moved his experiments out-of-doors on the family estate near Bologna, Italy, to communicate further. He replaced Hertz’s vertical dipole with a vertical wire topped by a metal sheet, with an opposing terminal connected to the ground. On the receiver side, Marconi replaced the spark gap with a metal powder coherer, a detector developed by Edouard Branly and other experimenters. Marconi transmitted radio signals for about a mile at the end of 1895.
Marconi's Three; Transatlantic Radio Stations In Cape Breton.
Marconi's reputation is largely based on these accomplishments in radio communications and commercializing a practical system. His demonstrations of the use of radio for wireless communications, equipping ships with life saving wireless communications, establishing the first transatlantic radio service, and building the first stations for the British short wave service, have marked his place in history. Marconi and his company were not alone in the field; his principal competition came from German scientists whose work would become the basis for the
Telefunken company (which Nikola Tesla assisted in building).
Marconi's (
July 13, 1897) (and the reissued ) disclosed a two-circuit system for the transmission and reception of "Hertzian waves" (though he would later acknowledge that in the early wireless systems the "
waves do not propagate in the same manner as free radiation from a classical Hertzian oscillator, but surface wave"Marconi, "
Wireless Telegraphic Communication: Nobel Lecture, December 11, 1909." Nobel Lectures. Physics 1901-1921. Amsterdam: Elsevier Publishing Company, 1967: 196-222.). The transmitter was an antenna circuit, with an aerial plate and a ground plate, and a spark gap. Induced signals in the circuit were caused to discharge through a spark gap, producing oscillations which were radiated. The receiver contained an antenna circuit, an aerial plate and a ground plate, and a
coherer. Marconi's apparatus was to be resonant (commonly called by various researcheres at the time syntonic). This was done by the careful determination of the size of the aerial plates.
The Poldhu experiment
In 1901, Marconi claimed to have received daytime transatlantic radio frequency signals at a medium frequency (820 kHz).Henry M. Bradford, "
Marconi in Newfoundland: The 1901 Transatlantic Radio Experiment".Henry M. Bradford, "
Did Marconi Receive Transatlantic Radio Signals in 1901? - Part 1". Wolfville, N.S..Henry M. Bradford, "
Did Marconi Receive Transatlantic Radio Signals in 1901? Part 2, Conclusion: The Trans-Atlantic Experiments". Wolfville, N.S.. The early spark transmitters
may have been broadly tuned and the Poldhu transmitter
may have radiated sufficient energy in that part of the spectrum for a transatlantic transmission,
if Marconi was using an untuned receiver when he claimed to have received the transatlantic signal at Newfoundland in 1901. When he used a tuned receiver aboard the SS Philadelphia in 1902, he could only receive a daytime signal from Poldhu, a distance of 700 miles,
less than half the distance from Poldhu to Newfoundland. At night the signals were reported to have been received several times further, and his successful transatlantic transmissions from Glace Bay, Nova Scotia in 1902 were made at night. Marconi would later found the
Marconi Company and would jointly receive the 1909 Nobel Prize in Physics with
Karl Ferdinand Braun.
Marconi’s 1901
Poldhu to
Colony of Newfoundland transmission claim has been attacked.John S. Belrose, "
Fessenden and Marconi; Their Differing Technologies and Transatlantic Experiments During the First Decade of this Century", International Conference on 100 Years of Radio, 5-7 September, 1995, (PDF file;
ed. accessed
April 14,
2006) Critics have claimed that it is more likely that Marconi received Signal noise from atmospheric electricity in the 1901 experiment. "Marconi's Error: The First Transatlantic Wireless Telegraphy in 1901" The transmitting station in Poldhu, Cornwall used a spark-gap transmitter that could produce a signal just below the medium frequency and with high power levels (a maximum time-averaged power of 35 kilowatts, but with a peak pulse power of megawatts). The message received was the morse letter 'S' - three dots. Dr Jack Belrose has recently contested this, however, based on theoretical work as well as a reenactment of the experiment; he believes that Marconi heard only random atmospheric noise and mistook it for the signal. There are various science historians who agree with Jack Belrose (in addition to being bolstered by Tesla supporters) that the Atlantic was not bridged in 1901, but other science historians have taken the position that this was the first trans-atlantic radio transmission.
Court decision
In 1943 a lawsuit regarding Marconi's numerous other radio patents was resolved by the U.S. Supreme Court, who overturned most of these. At the time, the
United States Army was involved in a patent infringement lawsuit with Marconi's company regarding radio, leading various observers to posit that the government nullified Marconi's other patents in order to moot any claims for compensation (as, it is speculated, the government's initial reversal to grant Marconi the patent right in order to nullify any claims Tesla had for compensation).
The court decision was based on the proven prior work conducted by others, such as by Tesla, Oliver Lodge, and
John Stone Stone, from which some of Marconi patents (such as ) stemmed. The U. S. Supreme Court stated that,
"
The Tesla patent No. 645,576, applied for September 2, 1897 and allowed March 20, 1900, disclosed a four-circuit system, having two circuits each at transmitter and receiver, and recommended that all four circuits be tuned to the same frequency. He
recognized that his apparatus could, without change, be used for wireless communication, which is dependent upon the transmission of electrical energy."U.S. Supreme Court, "
Marconi Wireless Telegraph co. of America v. United States". 320 U.S. 1. Nos. 369, 373. Argued April 9-12, 1943. Decided June 21,
1943.
In making their decision, the court noted,
"
Marconi's reputation as the man who first achieved successful radio transmission rests on his original patent, which became reissue No. 11,913, and which is not here U.S. 1, 38 in question. That reputation, however well-deserved, does not entitle him to a patent for every later improvement which he claims in the radio field. Patent cases, like others, must be decided not by weighing the reputations of the litigations, but by careful study of the merits of their respective contentions and proofs."
Wireless Telegraph co. of America v. United States.
The court also stated that,
"
It is well established that as between two inventors priority of invention will be awarded to the one who by satisfying proof can show that he first conceived of the invention."
Wireless Telegraph co. of America v. United States.
Case of priority
Case for Marconi
Marconi supporters have stated that Marconi was not aware of the works of
Nikola Tesla in the United States. It is unlikely, though, that Marconi was unaware of Tesla's presentations. Both
On Light and Other High Frequency Phenomena (Philadelphia/St. Louis; Franklin Institute in 1893) and
Experiments with Alternating Currents of High Potential and High Frequency (London; 1892) were reported on internationally. Tesla's 1893 presentation at the Franklin Institute was reported across America (such as in
The Century Magazine) and throughout Europe.Ljubo Vujovi, "
Tesla Biography; Nikola Tesla, The genius who lit the world". Teslasociety.com. Tesla also performed public demonstrations of actual and related work, such as the remote-controlled boat in 1898 (which was protected under ). The remote-controlled boat contained "rotating
coherers" that allowed secure communication between transmitter and receiver.
Case against Marconi
By 1895, Marconi introduced to the public a device in
London, asserting it was his invention. Despite Marconi's statements to the contrary, though, the apparatus resembles Tesla's descriptions in the widely translated articles. P.J.Papadopoulos, " Nikola Tesla; The Guglielmo Marconi Case, Who is the True Inventor of Radio?" Marconi's later practical four-tuned system was pre-dated by N. Tesla,
History of radio#Oliver Lodge, and J. S. Stone. Tesla was the first, though, to expound the principles of the four-tuned system. The earlier two-tuned systems were not practical for commercial activity (as found in the United States court case). In addition, other prior work was conducted by others (such as by Hertz and Bruan, but not excluding others) from which many of Marconi's devices and methods were derived. Marconi's
Apparatus for wireless telegraphy , in which a more intricate system was disclosed than in his earlier patents, was filed after contributions made by other investigators. Marconi’s late-1895 transmission of signals was for around a mile. This was small when put against Tesla's early-1895 transmissions of up to 50 miles.
Case for Tesla
Nikola Tesla was first to hold the rights to radio:
- , "System of Transmission of Electrical Energy", March 20, 1900 (March 20, 1900; filed Sept. 2, 1897).
- , "Apparatus for Transmission of Electrical Energy" (May 15, 1900; filed February 19, 1900).
Tesla's system can produce a variety of wave propagations, pending the driving apparatus. Tesla believed that his wireless system would be better than most other radio systems because Transverse wave (whose behavior depends on their wavelength) would decay as they travelled from the transmitter, making the signals uselessly weak at long distances. Tesla advanced that
Longitudinal wave (such as those that occur in waves in plasmas) through the medium would be used, as he theorized that they would be practically lossless. His devices can be driven to produce either transverse or longitudinal waves.
There is also the relevance of Tesla demonstrations of the remote-controlled boat (with its internal rotating
coherer) as well as Tesla's public lecture demonstrations. Besides his intention to transmit wireless signals of intelligence, he proposed to transmit electric power via
electrical conduction through the earth and the upper atmosphere, as well as in between them both (in the earth-ionosphere region which is now known as a cavity resonator). This power transmission was to be done not by "hertzian waves," but through
standing wave surface waves. Tesla’s proposed wireless transmitter utilized a resonant transformer to apply a very high voltage of high frequency between the earth and a large elevated conductor, as discussed earlier.
Case against Tesla
Tesla never completed his "worldwide wireless system," primarily because of financial difficulties. Cost overruns stopped him from completing the Wardenclyffe Tower (a "wireless station tower") that he built in the early 1900s in
Shoreham, New York on
Long Island, New York.
Timeline
The identity of the original inventor of radio, at the time called wireless telegraphy, is contentious. The key invention for the beginning of "wireless transmission of data using the entire frequency spectrum" has been attributed to various inventors and researchers. Below is a chart of important events and individuals related to the development of radio.ImageSize = width:777 height:633DateFormat = YYYYPeriod = from:1860 till:1960PlotArea = width:665 height:600 left:33 bottom:25TimeAxis = orientation:vertical order:reverseScaleMajor = unit:year increment:10 start:1860ScaleMinor = unit:year increment:1 start:1860PlotData= at:1864 fontsize:S text:"[James Clerk Maxwell predicts electromagnetic (EM) waves using a transmission medium.
at:1872 fontsize:S text:"[Mahlon Loomis and W. H. Ward (USA) file for U.S. Patents for a "wireless telegraph"."
at:1878 fontsize:S text:"[David Edward Hughes transcieves via induction transmission."
at:1885 fontsize:S text:"[Thomas Alva Edison uses a vibrator magnet for induction transmission. [Heinrich Rudolf Hertz begins EM wave experiments".
at:1887 fontsize:S text:"[Heinrich Rudolf Hertz publishes his research in the journal Annalen der Physik. Edison installs signalling syetem at the Lehigh Valley Railroad."
at:1891 fontsize:S text:"[Nikola Tesla is granted U.S. Patents No. 447,920, and 447,921 (VLF generators) and 454,622 (RF power supply). Edison receives U. S. Patent No. 465971.
at:1893 fontsize:S text:"Tesla demonstrates wireless techniques at the Franklin Institute in Philadelphia."
at:1895 text:"[Alexander Stepanovich Popov presents his radio receiver to the Russian Physical and Chemical Society."
at:1897 fontsize:S text:"[Guglielmo Marconi is granted British patent No. 12,039 (Radio patent). Tesla is granted U.S. Patents No. 645,576 and 649,621 (Four-tuned circuit patents)."
at:1901 fontsize:S text:"[Wardenclyffe Tower is opened by Tesla. Marconi receives British patent No. 7,777 and reports transatlantic transmission."
at:1904 fontsize:S text:"[John Ambrose Fleming develops the "oscillation valve" (vacuum-tube diode). "
at:1906 fontsize:S text:"[Lee De Forest invents the [Audion tube, now known as the vacuum-tube [triode."
at:1909 fontsize:S text:"[Karl Ferdinand Braun and Marconi receive Nobel Prize in physics, 'in recognition of their contributions to the development of wireless telegraphy'."
at:1922 fontsize:S text:"[BBC begins broadcasting from London."
at:1928 fontsize:S text:"[Julius Edgar Lilienfeld patents the transistor principle in Germany"
at:1933 fontsize:S text:"[Edwin Howard Armstrong patents FM ([frequency modulation)"
at:1943 fontsize:S text:"Marconi's radio patents in the United States overturned due to prior art."
at:1947 fontsize:S text:"[William Shockley, [John Bardeen and [Walter Brattain build the [transistor."
at:1956 fontsize:S text:"Shockley, Bardeen and Brattain receive the Nobel Prize in Physics for the invention of the transistor."
See also
Notes
References
- "Marconi Wireless Telegraphy Company of America v United States", 320 U.S. 1. Nos. 369, 373. Argued April 9-12, 1943. Decided June 21, 1943 http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/printer_friendly.pl?page=us/320/1.html
- Anderson, L.I., "Priority in the Invention of Radio: Tesla vs. Marconi", Antique Wireless Association Monograph No. 4, March, 1980.
- Anderson, L.I., "John Stone Stone on Nikola Tesla's Priority in Radio and Continuous-Wave Radiofrequency Apparatus", The A.W.A. (Antique Wireless Association) Review, Vol. 1, 1986, pp. 18-41.
- Wunsch, A.D., "Misreading the Supreme Court,” Antenna, Volume 11 No. 1, November 1998, Society for the History of Technology http://www.mercurians.org/nov98/misreading.html
- Brand, W.E., "Rereading the Supreme Court: Tesla's Invention of Radio", Antenna, Volume 11 No. 2, May 1998, Society for the History of Technology http://www.mercurians.org/may99/rereading.html
Invention of radio - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Within the timeline of radio, many people were involved in the invention of radio transmission of information as we know it today. Despite this, during its early development and ...
History of radio - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
... Telephony, and Transmission of Power", Sun Publishing Company, LC 92-60482, ISBN 0-9632652-0-2 (ed. excerpts available online) Anderson, Leland I. Priority in the Invention of Radio ...
BBC - Radio 4 - The Invention of Childhood
The invention of childhood - a narrative history covering a thousand of British childhood in thirty episodes. ... For those who missed all or parts of it earlier in the year, there ...
BBC - Radio 4 - The Invention of Childhood Picture Gallery
The invention of childhood gallery - the series is a narrative history covering a thousand of British childhood in thirty episodes. ... Depiction of beggars and tramps with their ...
The Invention of Radio
An outline of the development of radio technology - radio owes its development to two other inventions the telegraph and the telephone.
The Invention of Radio
Radio was initially imaged as a wireless telegraph; the idea of broadcasting was a separate invention
BBC/OU Open2.net - The Invention of Childhood
How has childhood - and our attitude to it - changed over the centuries? ... The Invention of Childhood BBC Radio 4 begins a major 30 part series about the history of British ...
Marconi and the invention of radio (1915-1943) | Technology ...
Controversy continues over the origins of radio, but Marconi made it his own. ... Controversy still reigns over the question of who invented the radio, but there is little doubt ...
Through the Wires: Radio Invention
Radio is the branch of telecommunication that involves the propagation of electromagnetic waves through space. Read about the origination of the radio, AM and FM waves, ham ... The ...
Invention: Radio
The Beginning First developed in 1879, the first radios were bulky, noisy, and had poor reception. With the advent of improved technologies such as vacuum tubes and rectifiers, the ...